Published by admin on 28 May 2008
Major Newspaper Justifies Polygamy!
(The following article recently appeared in the opinion section of one of the largest newspapers in the United States.)
“The Court Got it Right”
Last week, the Supreme Court made the right call: Excluding loving, committed adults from polygamous marriages harms them and their families and in the end doesn’t help anyone. Exclusion also violates the constitution’s command of equality for all. Americans, after all, value fairness and inclusion. Even if we don’t agree with the practice of polygamists, we can’t deny them the rights to legal marriage and recognition as equals in our society.
Many of these men genuinely love their wives and children, and these wives love their husbands. Alternative lifestyles are something our culture has been embracing for years now. And, polygamous families are only an extension of that inclusive principle. Besides, think of the harm it does these children to be taken from their mothers and father. One can only imagine how disorienting it must be for a child to live in a family with multiple mothers, only to have the ‘anti-polygamy’ industry, supported by the State, split up the family and attempt to ‘retrain’ them to believe in another definition of marriage.
When these polygamy-haters attack these judges for doing their job, they need to realize they are attacking the judicial branch of government meant to protect us from legislative and moral oppression. We should be thankful to have such brave and constitution-minded judges on the bench throughout our land.
What do you think?
So, what do you make of these arguments? Do they change your mind about polygamy? “Ludicrous,” you say. Indeed. Why? Because polygamy is wrong, and it doesn’t matter how you spin it. You can’t use a fairness and equality argument to justify something morally wrong. No matter how loving or devoted these parents are to their children or each other, their actions are still wrong and should be rejected by the culture. No matter how much we value treating people fairly and equally, we can’t sanction immoral, destructive behavior so we can be ‘fair.’